Emmanuel Ochayi
Detroit Judge Faces Backlash for Courtroom Incident
A Detroit judge has been temporarily removed from his duties following an incident involving a 15-year-old girl, Eva Goodman, during a courtroom visit.
The incident, which has sparked outrage and led to an internal investigation, has brought significant attention to the actions of Judge Kenneth King of the 36th District Court.
Join our WhatsApp ChannelIncident During Educational Field Trip
Eva was part of an educational trip organized by the environmental charity The Greening, known for its outdoor activities like kayaking and bird-watching.
The trip included a visit to Judge King’s courtroom, where the incident unfolded. According to reports, Judge King noticed Eva allegedly falling asleep during the proceedings, which led him to take drastic measures.
Judge King, dissatisfied with Eva’s “attitude,” decided to make an example of her. “One thing you’ll learn about my courtroom is that I’m not a toy. I am not to be played with,” King told Eva and her mother during the visit.
He then asked the other students on the trip to vote on whether Eva should be sent to a juvenile detention center. Ultimately, he decided to have her handcuffed and dressed in a jail uniform, although she was released soon after.
Judge Defends His Actions
In response to the backlash, Judge King defended his actions, stating, “It was her whole attitude and her whole disposition that disturbed me.
I wanted to get through to her, show how serious this is.” He explained that he intended to give Eva a “real” experience, likening his approach to the “Scared Straight” programs designed to deter youth from criminal behavior.
Judge King also acknowledged that there was little real chance of Eva being jailed but insisted that his actions were meant to prevent her from ending up in court in the future.
READ ALSO: US Judge Dismisses Trump’s Classified Document Case
“I’ll do whatever needs to be done to reach these kids and make sure that they don’t end up in front of me,” he added.
Outrage from Eva’s Family
Eva’s mother, Latoreya Hill, expressed her deep dismay over the judge’s actions. In a local news interview, Hill asked, “Would you want someone to treat your child like that? To belittle her in front of the whole world and her friends, to make her feel even worse about her situation?”
Hill provided context for her daughter’s behavior, explaining that Eva did not have “her own bed that she can sleep in” and was simply tired during the court visit. As a single mother of two, Hill voiced her frustration, stating, “I’m trying my best.”
Court’s Response and Temporary Removal
Chief Judge William McConico, who oversees the 36th District Court, responded to the incident by announcing Judge King’s temporary removal from his cases.
McConico emphasized the importance of maintaining strong relationships with local schools and expressed hope that the incident would not damage those partnerships.
Judge Aliyah Sabree, the court’s second-in-command, also condemned Judge King’s actions, stating that they did “not reflect the standards” of the court. She assured the public that the matter would be addressed with “the utmost diligence.”
Moving Forward
Despite defending his actions, Judge King’s decision has led to a broader discussion about appropriate behavior in the courtroom, especially when dealing with minors.
The court’s swift action to temporarily remove him and mandate necessary training reflects its commitment to ensuring that such incidents are handled more appropriately in the future.
As the investigation continues, the incident serves as a reminder of the delicate balance required to maintain authority in the courtroom while also treating individuals, especially minors, with respect and dignity.
